Forum Message

Topic: Reply
Posted by: Richard Carter
Date/Time: 08/04/26 11:46:00

"There have been several examples of this on the Forum including false accusations of genocide, an implicit comparison with the Holocaust, and most recently a description of extremist settlers as Nazi brownshirts."

Theres a lot to unpick here, but I'll try.

The accusation of genocide was made by Sourh Africa and, when considered by the International Court of Justice, was described as "plausible," so dismissing it as "false" is a triumph of hope over evidence. Better to wait for the conclusion of the case.

Second, on "an implicit comparison with the Holocaust," this invoking of the Holocaust as an instant excuse for whatever Israel's defence forces get up to is becoming rather tired.

Finally, the comparison of what even you admit to be extremist settlers with the Brownshirts is indeed valid - not in their ideology which is obviously different, but the behaviour. Perhaps you could explain how attacking, killing and injuring Palestinians, burning their houses, denying access to their crops and burning or uprooting olive groves and generally making their lives impossible, is functionally different from what the Brownshiirts did. And, by the way, invoking the Holocaust in this context is invalid because that terrible event was far into the future from when the Brownshirts rampaged through Germany in the 1930s.


Entire Thread
TopicDate PostedPosted By
Is Trump completely unhinged?06/04/26 09:21:00 Richard Carter
   Reply06/04/26 10:43:00 Michael Ixer
      Re:Reply06/04/26 11:38:00 Jonathan Callaway
         Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 11:53:00 Jonathan Callaway
            Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 12:40:00 Gerry Boyce
               Reply06/04/26 13:11:00 Michael Ixer
      Reply07/04/26 17:17:00 Michael Ixer
   Reply06/04/26 13:23:00 Michael Ixer
      Re:Reply06/04/26 13:57:00 Gerry Boyce
   Re:Is Trump completely unhinged?06/04/26 13:52:00 Ivonne Holliday
      Reply06/04/26 14:16:00 Michael Ixer
         Re:Reply06/04/26 16:28:00 Ivonne Holliday
            Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 16:58:00 Steven Rose
               Reply06/04/26 17:50:00 Michael Ixer
                  Re:Reply06/04/26 18:01:00 Steven Rose
                     Is Trump Completely Unhinged?06/04/26 18:13:00 Sue Hammond
                        Reply06/04/26 18:24:00 Michael Ixer
                           Re:Reply06/04/26 18:37:00 Sue Hammond
                              Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 20:17:00 Ivonne Holliday
                                 Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 21:19:00 Sue Hammond
                                    Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 22:29:00 Ivonne Holliday
                                    Reply06/04/26 22:50:00 Michael Ixer
                        Re:Is Trump Completely Unhinged?06/04/26 18:43:00 Gerry Boyce
                     Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 19:45:00 Ivonne Holliday
            Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 18:34:00 Gerry Boyce
   Reply06/04/26 19:13:00 Michael Ixer
      Re:Reply06/04/26 19:25:00 Robert Wheeler
         Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 19:54:00 Steven Rose
            Reply06/04/26 20:01:00 Michael Ixer
            Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 20:30:00 Gerry Boyce
               Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 20:50:00 Robert Wheeler
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 21:28:00 Michael Brigo
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 22:06:00 Gerry Boyce
                     Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 22:49:00 Steven Rose
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 23:32:00 Gerry Boyce
                        Reply06/04/26 23:44:00 Michael Ixer
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply06/04/26 23:58:00 Michael Brigo
                           Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply07/04/26 00:03:00 Michael Brigo
   Reply07/04/26 09:36:00 Richard Carter
      Re:Reply07/04/26 10:11:00 Steven Rose
         Re:Re:Reply07/04/26 13:24:00 John Hawkes
         Reply07/04/26 13:53:00 Richard Carter
            Re:Reply07/04/26 16:29:00 John Hawkes
      Re:Reply07/04/26 10:44:00 Ivonne Holliday
         Re:Re:Reply07/04/26 14:13:00 Gerry Boyce
            Reply07/04/26 17:14:00 Michael Ixer
   Reply07/04/26 15:23:00 Michael Brigo
      Re:Reply07/04/26 16:24:00 Steven Rose
         Re:Re:Reply07/04/26 17:11:00 John Hawkes
            Re:Re:Re:Reply08/04/26 11:30:00 John Hawkes
         Re:Re:Reply07/04/26 17:17:00 Ivonne Holliday
            Re:Re:Re:Reply07/04/26 18:25:00 Steven Rose
               Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply07/04/26 18:43:00 Ivonne Holliday
               Reply08/04/26 11:46:00 Richard Carter
                  Re:Reply08/04/26 12:02:00 John Hawkes
   Re:Is Trump completely unhinged?07/04/26 19:15:00 Steven Rose
   Reply08/04/26 13:16:00 Richard Carter
      Re:Reply08/04/26 13:32:00 John Hawkes
      Re:Reply08/04/26 15:59:00 John Hawkes
         Re:Re:Reply08/04/26 18:03:00 Steven Rose
            Re:Re:Re:Reply09/04/26 17:52:00 John Hawkes
            Re:Re:Re:Reply09/04/26 21:20:00 Gerry Boyce
               Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 11:54:00 John Hawkes
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 13:01:00 Gerry Boyce
                     Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 16:02:00 John Hawkes
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 16:28:00 Gerry Boyce
                           Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply11/04/26 14:22:00 Gerry Boyce
      Re:Reply08/04/26 18:02:00 Ivonne Holliday
   Reply09/04/26 19:15:00 Michael Ixer
      Re:Reply09/04/26 20:16:00 Gerry Boyce
         Re:Re:Reply09/04/26 22:25:00 Steven Rose
            Re:Re:Re:Reply09/04/26 23:41:00 Michael Brigo
               Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 00:43:00 Steven Rose
                  Reply10/04/26 12:02:00 Richard Carter
         Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 12:03:00 John Hawkes
            Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 12:20:00 Gerry Boyce
               Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 16:46:00 John Hawkes
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 17:16:00 Gerry Boyce
      Re:Reply10/04/26 12:01:00 John Hawkes
         Reply10/04/26 13:27:00 Michael Ixer
   Reply10/04/26 11:45:00 Michael Ixer
      Re:Reply10/04/26 12:13:00 Gerry Boyce
         Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 12:33:00 Steven Rose
            Reply10/04/26 13:08:00 Richard Carter
               Re:Reply10/04/26 18:18:00 Steven Rose
                  Reply10/04/26 21:19:00 Richard Carter
                  Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 21:21:00 Gerry Boyce
                     Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 22:14:00 Steven Rose
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply10/04/26 22:20:00 Gerry Boyce
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply11/04/26 11:26:00 John Hawkes
                           Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply11/04/26 18:32:00 Steven Rose
                              Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply11/04/26 21:37:00 Gerry Boyce
                                 Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply11/04/26 21:56:00 Steven Rose
                                    Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Reply11/04/26 22:23:00 Gerry Boyce
                                    Reply11/04/26 22:26:00 Sue Hammond

Forum Home