Forum Message

Topic: Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?
Posted by: David Austin
Date/Time: 25/08/16 11:17:00

Excellent question Sarah. One wonders if he has actually read the valuation report which he claims has been over-egged by the highly reputable Montagu Evans. If he has, how about him detailing here which parts of the report have led him to this conclusion?

Also, he says it is his "belief" that there is no reasonable chance of recovering the money. I would personally like a little bit more to go on than that - but in any case, it was the trustees who arranged to get a valuation as a first step in resolving this matter: to establish if there is a loss and then to find out how and who to recover it from. This is the course of action agreed not by the petitioners, not John Cameron and Nick Evans - but by the trustees. He appears therefore to be criticising the WPCC as much as the petition. Also, for the record, it is the WPCC that said that it had put its insurers on notice last year about making a claim for this loss.

The real question is why the WPCC has taken so long to commission a new valuation, why it refuses to accept the current and perfectly good on that the WPCC had already commissioned and which it has now paid for - and those questions lead to the petition.

There are more details about that now on the front page of the SW15 news page.


Entire Thread
TopicDate PostedPosted By
WPCC Petition23/08/16 16:06:00 David Austin
   Re:WPCC Petition23/08/16 18:07:00 Adam Gray
      Re:Re:WPCC Petition23/08/16 18:14:00 Nicholas Evans
         Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition23/08/16 18:24:00 Sue Hammond
         Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition29/08/16 11:36:00 Jane Carter
            A Conservator Replies ....I Have No Idea29/08/16 11:59:00 John Cameron
            Re:Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition photograph29/08/16 13:39:00 Nicholas Evans
      Re:Re:WPCC Petition23/08/16 18:49:00 David Austin
         Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition24/08/16 12:01:00 William Smith
            A Conservator Writes....24/08/16 13:56:00 John Cameron
               Re:A Conservator Writes....24/08/16 14:23:00 Adam Tripp
                  Re:Re:A Conservator Writes....24/08/16 14:38:00 John Cameron
                     Re:Re:Re:A Conservator Writes....24/08/16 14:42:00 Stephen Walker
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:A Conservator Writes....24/08/16 14:59:00 John Cameron
                           Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:A Conservator Writes....25/08/16 14:14:00 Stephen Walker
                     Re:Re:Re:A Conservator Writes....24/08/16 15:10:00 Adam Tripp
            Re:Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition24/08/16 14:21:00 Nicholas Evans
               Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition24/08/16 16:12:00 William Smith
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition24/08/16 16:55:00 Nicholas Evans
                     Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition24/08/16 18:07:00 David Austin
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:WPCC Petition24/08/16 20:10:00 Andy Pike
                           Total Baloney24/08/16 22:43:00 Jonty Nicholls
                              Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?24/08/16 22:59:00 John Cameron
                                 Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?25/08/16 01:43:00 Sarah Roberts
                                    Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?25/08/16 11:17:00 David Austin
                                       Re:Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?27/08/16 23:14:00 Jonty Nicholls
                                    Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?27/08/16 23:03:00 Jonty Nicholls
                                       Re:Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?28/08/16 09:14:00 Nicholas Evans
                                          Re:Re:Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?28/08/16 09:34:00 Sarah Roberts
                                             Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?28/08/16 10:29:00 Chantal Blake-Milton
                                                A Conservator Replies.....I Have No Idea 29/08/16 12:02:00 John Cameron
                                             Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?29/08/16 23:55:00 Jonty Nicholls
                                                Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Misleading Jonty Nicholls...?30/08/16 09:20:00 Nicholas Evans
                                          Re:Re:Re:Re:Who Do You Think You Are Kidding Jonty Nicholls...?30/08/16 00:03:00 Jonty Nicholls
                                             Re:Clarification30/08/16 00:17:00 Jonty Nicholls
                                                Re:Re:Clarification30/08/16 09:13:00 David Austin
                                                   Re:Re:Re:Clarification03/09/16 00:31:00 Jonty Nicholls
                                                      Bump07/09/16 13:23:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                         Re:Bump07/09/16 19:28:00 Claire Morgan
                                                            Re:Re:Bump07/09/16 19:46:00 David Austin
                                                               Re:Re:Re:Bump07/09/16 21:57:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                                  Thank you Guy09/09/16 13:19:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                                     Thank you Martine Guy09/09/16 13:22:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                                        Re:Thank you Martine Guy09/09/16 13:37:00 Martine Guy
                                                                           Re:Re:Thank you Martine Guy09/09/16 14:00:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                                              Thank you Tom Simons09/09/16 20:14:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                                                 Re:Thank you Sarah10/09/16 00:10:00 Guy Sunda
                                                                                    Re:Re:Thank you Sarah10/09/16 07:23:00 Tom Simons
                                                                                       A Councillor Writes.... 10/09/16 08:13:00 John Cameron
                                                                                          Re:A Councillor Writes.... 10/09/16 09:13:00 Sue Hammond
                                                            "Trust in me, trust in me"10/09/16 09:35:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                               Re:"Trust in me, trust in me"10/09/16 09:50:00 Sue Hammond
                                                                  Wandsworth's Threat to WPCC10/09/16 10:26:00 John Cameron
                                                                     Re:Wandsworth's Threat to WPCC10/09/16 12:21:00 Nick Parker
                                                                        WBC's Threatened More Than a CP10/09/16 12:57:00 John Cameron
                                                               Re:"Trust in me, trust in me"10/09/16 12:36:00 Claire Morgan
                                                                  Never wrong.  Ruthless to the end12/09/16 06:32:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                                     Re:Never wrong.  Ruthless to the end12/09/16 11:20:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                                        Re:Re:Never wrong.  Ruthless to the end12/09/16 11:21:00 Sarah Roberts
                                                                           Third Sector Magazine19/09/16 11:22:00 Sarah Roberts

Forum Home