Forum Message

Topic: Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think
Posted by: Richard Carter
Date/Time: 22/01/10 16:20:00

Some interesting points, but I don't think they answer the argument, though:

- NOx emissions may be greater from diesel than from petrol, but how much greater? I can't find any figures from a quick search, and without more data the comparison doesn't tell us much. And factor in that the occupancy level is much higher for buses than for cars/vans, and the NOx emissions per person will tell a very different story.

- Yes, a high proportion of diesel-engined buses, but I would guess (again without data) that only a small proportion of them have just started from Chelverton Road garage.

- I doubt very much whether the position of the monitor has a significant effect on the reading, and before you could compare PHS with Earls Court Road you would, on this basis, have also to see where the monitors were placed there.

One final point: it's not just to reduce noxious emissions that we need to reduce traffic in PHS and elsewhere.


Entire Thread
TopicDate PostedPosted By
Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think21/01/10 01:02:00 Richard Carter
   Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think21/01/10 08:29:00 Jane Holland
      Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think21/01/10 17:29:00 Bunny Payne
         Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think21/01/10 19:06:00 Richard Carter
            Re:Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think21/01/10 20:59:00 Jonathan Callaway
               Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think21/01/10 22:40:00 Roland Gilmore
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think21/01/10 23:15:00 Craig Fordham
                     Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think21/01/10 23:54:00 Richard Carter
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 01:13:00 Fraser Pearce
                           Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 08:22:00 Roland Gilmore
                              Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 10:55:00 Richard Carter
   Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 10:38:00 Peter Simpson
      Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 10:54:00 Simon Kelly
         Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 11:40:00 Richard Carter
         Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 13:57:00 Richard Hodges
            Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 16:20:00 Richard Carter
               Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think25/01/10 14:36:00 Richard Hodges
   Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 12:43:00 M Blissett
      Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think22/01/10 16:53:00 David Wilson
         Re:Re:Re:Come and enjoy the lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think23/01/10 14:45:00 Simon Knight
            Re: lovely air in Putney High Street - I don't think23/01/10 21:37:00 Alan Thomson

Forum Home